Were Hawthorn Robbed by the Umpires? The Controversial Call That Ended Their Season
In a thrilling AFL preliminary final at the MCG, the Brisbane Lions snatched a nine-point victory over Hawthorn, ending the Hawks' premiership hopes with a late holding-the-ball free kick. While Hawthorn fans questioned the consistency of umpiring, analysis suggests the decision was correct under the rules. Key moments, including a costly third-quarter lapse and missed opportunities, were pivotal in Hawthorn's loss. Post-match, unacceptable bottle-throwing marred the aftermath, but the consensus remains: critical errors earlier in the match were more decisive than umpiring in Hawthorn’s heartbreak.
- Brisbane edge Hawthorn by 9 points in a dramatic AFL preliminary final.
- Late holding-the-ball free kick correct but raises questions about consistency.
- Hawthorn's earlier missed opportunities and third-quarter fadeout proved costly.
Hawthorn's premiership dream came to a heartbreaking end at the MCG on Saturday night, with a controversial holding-the-ball decision in the dying seconds helping Brisbane snatch a nine-point victory and book a spot in the 2026 AFL Grand Final.
The Hawks had somehow fought back from 28 points down in the final quarter to hit the front, only for Hugh McCluggage to convert a free kick with 18 seconds remaining before Kai Lohmann added another goal after the siren.
Brisbane prevailed 20.11 (131) to 19.8 (122) in front of 97,835 spectators, leaving Hawthorn players and supporters shattered and plenty of debate about whether the Hawks were robbed by the umpires.
Were Hawthorn robbed by the umpires?
The short answer is no, at least when it comes to the holding-the-ball decision against Jarman Impey that ultimately put Brisbane back in front.
With the Hawks desperately defending a three-point lead, Impey gathered possession deep in defence and was immediately wrapped up by McCluggage, who pinned one of his arms in the tackle.
Impey still had an arm free but failed to make a genuine attempt to dispose of the football, leaving the umpire with little option but to award the free kick.
It was the correct decision under the holding-the-ball interpretation, and McCluggage still had to go back and convert his set shot from approximately 30 metres out on a slight angle.
However, Hawthorn supporters have every right to question the consistency of the umpiring.
How many times do we see players tackled in similar circumstances, with one arm pinned, only for the umpire to call for a ball-up?
The frustration isn't necessarily with the decision itself but with whether the same interpretation was applied throughout the contest. If it is holding the ball in the final 30 seconds of a preliminary final, it needs to be holding the ball in the opening minute as well.
The earlier insufficient-intent decision against Mitch Lewis was arguably the more contentious of the two late calls.
Lewis was penalised after knocking a bouncing ball over the boundary line while under pressure from Harris Andrews, despite appearing to have little opportunity to take clean possession.
That one was far more debatable, but the subsequent decision against Impey was there.
Where did Hawthorn really lose the game?
It is easy to focus on the final 30 seconds, but Hawthorn had several opportunities to put the result beyond Brisbane's reach.
The Hawks led by 14 points at half-time after some brilliant attacking football, kicking 11.1 (67) across the opening two quarters.
They then had opportunities to extend that advantage early in the third term, with Jai Newcombe, Massimo D'Ambrosio and Jack Gunston all registering behinds in the opening five minutes.
Instead of putting Brisbane under further scoreboard pressure, Hawthorn left the door open, and the Lions made them pay.
Brisbane piled on seven goals to Hawthorn's one in the third quarter, turning a 14-point half-time deficit into a 20-point lead at the final change.
Kai Lohmann was particularly damaging with three goals for the term as the Lions completely swung the momentum.
The numbers also highlight where Brisbane gained the upper hand.
The Lions won the inside-50 count 62-55, centre clearances 22-15 and marks inside 50 by 19-13. Hawthorn finished just one clearance behind overall, but Brisbane's ability to win the ball out of the middle and generate quality opportunities in attack proved costly.
The Hawks somehow found another gear in the final quarter, piling on seven goals as Nick Watson finished with six for the match.
They turned a 28-point deficit into a three-point lead and looked destined for the Grand Final before the dramatic final moments.
But the reality is that Hawthorn conceded seven goals in the third quarter, missed opportunities to build a more substantial lead and allowed Brisbane to generate too many scoring chances from centre clearances.
The final umpiring decision will be the moment everyone remembers, but there were plenty of others that contributed to the result.
Bottle-throwing controversy mars the aftermath
The dramatic finish was followed by ugly scenes as bottles and other objects were thrown towards the umpires as they left the MCG.
The incidents were captured on camera, with the behaviour drawing criticism from former Hawthorn captain Luke Hodge and Hawks coach Sam Mitchell.
There is no doubt Hawthorn supporters had every reason to be devastated after watching their side come from 28 points down, hit the front and then lose in the final seconds.
But throwing bottles at umpires is completely unacceptable, regardless of how controversial a decision might be.
The actions of a small number of spectators should not overshadow what was an extraordinary preliminary final, nor should they be used to paint the entire Hawthorn supporter base with the same brush.
Where does this rank among the most heartbreaking preliminary final losses?
Hawthorn's defeat will take some time to get over, particularly given the manner in which the Hawks fought their way back into the contest.
There have been some extraordinary preliminary final finishes over the years, and Saturday night's thriller deserves to be mentioned in the same conversation as these three classics.
1987 – Melbourne v Hawthorn
Hawthorn won by 2 points
Melbourne looked set to advance to the Grand Final before Jim Stynes ran across the mark, conceding a 15-metre penalty that brought Gary Buckenara within scoring range. Buckenara converted after the siren to send Hawthorn through and leave the Demons devastated. Stynes would later enjoy redemption by winning the 1991 Brownlow Medal.
1994 – North Melbourne v Geelong
Geelong won by 6 points
With scores level in the dying seconds, Gary Ablett took a mark in the goalsquare as the siren sounded. The Cats champion converted to send Geelong into the Grand Final, leaving North Melbourne to contemplate a heartbreaking exit.
1999 – Essendon v Carlton
Carlton won by 1 point
Essendon entered the preliminary final as overwhelming favourites but suffered a stunning one-point defeat. Dean Wallis was caught by Fraser Brown in the closing moments as the Bombers' final attacking opportunity disappeared, with Carlton prevailing 16.8 (104) to 14.19 (103).
1997 – Western Bulldogs v Adelaide
Adelaide won by 2 points
The Western Bulldogs led by 31 points at half-time and looked destined for their first Grand Final since 1961 before Adelaide staged a remarkable comeback. The Bulldogs were left to rue several missed opportunities, including a controversial non-decision involving Chris Grant in the final quarter, before Darren Jarman kicked the winning goal to seal a heartbreaking two-point defeat, with the Crows prevailing 12.21 (93) to 13.13 (91).
Saturday night's encounter had all the ingredients of another September classic. A massive crowd, wild momentum swings, a seemingly impossible comeback and a controversial free kick that ultimately decided who would advance to the Grand Final.
For Hawthorn, the pain will be compounded by the fact that they had done the hard work to recover from 28 points down and were just seconds away from completing one of the great preliminary final comebacks.
Instead, Brisbane advanced to face Fremantle and kept their hopes of a third consecutive premiership alive. Brisbane are $1.62 favourites for the decider, while Fremantle are $2.20.
The Hawks weren't robbed by the final holding-the-ball decision, but their supporters have every right to question the consistency of the umpiring.
Ultimately, Hawthorn will look back on a third-quarter fadeout, missed opportunities and several crucial moments that allowed Brisbane to remain in the contest.
They will also look back on a preliminary final that was there for the taking, only to slip through their fingers in the most heartbreaking fashion.
Verdict
AFL Grand Final betting odds
Brisbane
Win
@8/13 - 1 Unit
Bet £10 Get £30
with bonus code NEWBONUS
Available to new customers only. Make a qualifying deposit of £5 or more and claim the offer within 30 days of registering your account to qualify for 300% of that amount in Bet Credits, up to a maximum of £30 in Bet Credits. Once released, your Bet Credits will be held in your account balance and are non-withdrawable. Min deposit requirement. Free Bets are paid as Bet Credits and are available for use upon settlement of qualifying bets. Min odds, bet and payment method exclusions apply. Returns exclude Bet Credits stake. Registration required. Time limits and T&Cs apply. The bonus code NEWBONUS can be used during registration but does not change the offer amount in any way. #ad
Fremantle
Win
@6/5 - 1 Unit
Bet £10 Get £10
Promo Code: NEWBONUS
New customers only. Bet £10+ to receive £10 in Free Bets. 7-day free bet expiry. Stake not returned. Promotional Terms Apply. 18+. GambleAware.org
Based in Melbourne, Adam is an avid sporting fan that loves a day at the MCG to follow his team, Hawthorn, in the AFL and the Aussies in the cricket, while he doesn't mind a day out at Moonee Valley, Flemington and Caulfield from time to time.
Top Betting Sites
Betting offers
Upcoming Events
09 September 2026
- EuroVolley 2026 -
- Volleyball
15 September 2026
- RLCS 2026 World Championship -
- Esports
17 September 2026
- Logitech G Play Connect 2026 -
- Esports
- StarLadder StarSeries Fall 2026 -
- Esports
Load More
Today's Acca Tips
-
Soccer tips
-
Horse Racing tips
-
Tennis tips
