AFL
  • Home
  • AFL
timer

This preview has expired.

See all our latest betting tips or suggested betting sites

Geelong Cats vs Collingwood Magpies Tips - Cats in another close MCG blockbuster against Pies

adam-cusworth
Editor
Last updated: Mon 04 May 2026 23:57
Geelong Cats and Collingwood Magpies face off in another anticipated AFL thriller at the MCG, with recent history hinting at a close finish. Geelong, with a 5-3 record and standout form from Jeremy Cameron and Bailey Smith, are tipped to narrowly overcome Collingwood, who continue to boast defensive strength and elite midfielders like Nick Daicos. Both teams approach the contest with injuries and squad questions, but Geelong’s varied scoring options and structure are tipped to give them a slim edge. Expect a tense, defensively-minded encounter.
Adam Cusworth 04 May 2026
Share this article
Or copy link
  • Geelong have won 7 of the last 8 against Collingwood.
  • Both teams feature strong defenses; expect a tight contest.
  • Geelong's scoring depth should give them a narrow win.
Expired
Geelong vs Collingwood MCG
The Cats and the Magpies feature in a massive game on Saturday night at the MCG (Getty Images)

Geelong Cats vs Collingwood Magpies Preview


It shapes as another thrilling MCG blockbuster when Geelong take on Collingwood on Saturday night with the Cats set to scrape through in a tight one. 

The two sides have featured in plenty of tight contestst in recent times and there is plenty at play with little separating either side in their respective win-loss records so far this season. 

Geelong advanced to 5-3 last weekend with a 49-point win over North Melbourne, while Collingwood are 4-3 and a draw after splitting the points with Hawthorn last weekend with the two sides locked on 93 points apiece at the end of full time. 

Geelong’s will look to control the game through structure and adapt when things aren’t going their way. They were challenged for long periods last week before breaking the game open late and with Bailey Smith, Max Holmes and their midfield group able to rotate and impact in different phases, the Cats can shift the game on their terms when it matters most.

Collingwood, however, will ensure this is anything but straightforward. Their defensive resilience was on full display last week, absorbing a heavy inside 50 count and still managing to stay in the contest through efficiency and composure. 

Darcy Moore and their back six hold up well under pressure, while Nick Daicos continues to drive their ball movement and Jamie Elliott provides a dangerous outlet when they transition quickly.

The key difference in this matchup is Geelong’s ability to generate scoring from a wider range of avenues. Jeremy Cameron is in outstanding form and demands constant attention, while the likes of Jack Martin and the supporting forwards can capitalise when the ball hits the ground. Against a Collingwood side that prefers to defend deep and force low-percentage shots, Geelong’s patience and method going inside 50 will be crucial.

Expect a tight, contested game with both sides cancelling each other out for long periods. Take Geelong in a close one, with the total points under in play given both sides’ defensive strengths. Bailey Smith looms as a strong play for 30+ disposals, while Jack Martin is a sneaky option for 2+ goals.

  • Geelong have won seven of the past eight between the two sides. 
  • The past seven head to heads have been decided by 24 points or less. 
  • Jack Martin booted two goals last week and has kicked five in his past two against Collingwood are conceding an average of just 77 points per game. 
  • Collingwood rank #1 for fewest points conceded in 2026

Head to Head


The two sides fought out a thriller last season in the corresponding match when Collingwood missed with a shot after the siren, leaving Geelong with a three-point win. The Cats have won seven of the past eight between the two sides and the past seven have been decided by less than 24 points. 

Notable player performances in the recent head to heads come from;
  • Steele Sidebottom (Pies)- 25+ disposals in his past two against the Cats
  • Josh Daicos (Pies)- 30+ in two of his past three and 25+ in four of his past five
  • Bailey Smith (Cats)- 34+ disposals in three of his past four against the Pies
  • Jeremy Cameron (Cats)- 35 goals in his past 10 against the Pies
  • Jack Martin (Cats)- five goals in his past two against the Pies

Geelong Cats Form Analysis


Geelong come in with a 5-3 record and have handled a tough early draw well. They responded with a 30-point loss to Port Adelaide a fortnight ago, overcoming North Melbourne with a strong second half to win by 49 points in Round 8. . They were completely outplayed in a number of key statistical measures, includ 

Jeremy Cameron booted anoher three goals to take his season tally to 23 from seven matches. After a slow start to the season, he has kicked 19 in his past four, hitting the 3+ in all of those. 

Bailey Smith had 26 disposals against North Melbourne, ending his streak of six straight 30+ disposal games, while Max Holmes had 29 and has hit 25+ in every game this season.

Geelong’s key strength usually lies in a highly structured, system-driven game built around contest dominance and controlled ball movement, while they have a renowned ability to adapt to whatever situation each match brings. 

Geelong Cats Team News


Jack Henry was a late withdrawal from the win over North Melbourne and a decision on his availability will be made during the week. Gryan Miers is edging closer to a return from a knee injury but is unlikely to come up in time. Rhys Stanley, George Stevens, Mitch Knevitt and Jhye Clark all come off big games in the VFL and will be considered. 

Collingwood Magpies Form Analysis


Collingwood come in with a 4–3-1 win/loss/draw record after splitting their Round 8 fixture against Hawthorn at 93 apiece. They let slip a seven point lead with just ver a minute to go in that match in a contest that could have gone either way with Hawthorn dominating the inside 50 count (62-34) and generating 28 scoring shots to 18 in the 13.15 to 15.3 scoreline. 

A concern heading into this match is Collingwood’s record against finalists from last season. Prior to the match against Hawthorn, they were 0–8 in recent home-and-away encounters against sides that made the eight in 2025.

Positives for the Magpies in recent weeks have been there scoring and efficiency inside 50. Against Essendon in the ANZAC Day clash a fortnight ago they piled on 137 points, the first time they have broken that barrier this season, while they went close to that with 93 against Hawthorn. Jamie Elliott kicked three goals against the Hawks to take his season tally to 13, while Dan McStay sits on that number as well. 

Nick Daicos had 34 disposals against Hawthorn and has had 30 or more in every match this season, averaging a whopping 36.6 in 2026, the most of any player in the league. The former Port Adelaide player, Dan Houston, had one of his better games since arriving to the club at the start of 2025 with 32 disposals across half-back. 

Collingwood Magpies Team News


Collingwood pulled up with a number of concerns out of the Hawks match and Harry Perryman is set to miss with a hamstring injury, while Darcy Cameron (ankle) and Steele Sidebottom (hand) will be assessed during the week. Scott Pendlebury is expected to return after being managed and his appearance would see him equal the all-time games record of 432 set by Brent Harvey of North Melbourne. Bobby Hill continues to progress in the VFL and booted three goals at that level on the weekend. 

Verdict

Cats in a tight one with the defence of both sides to stand tall, Jack Martin a chance to sneak under the radar with a couple of goals
Best Bet1: Geelong 1-39 Margin @11/10 at Hollywood bets - 1 Unit
Best Bet2: Under 178.5 O/U @7/8 at bet365 - 1 Unit
Best Bet3: Jack Martin To Score 2+ goals @13/10 at Star Sports - 1 Unit
Geelong 1-39
Margin
@11/10 - 1 Unit
£30 Free Bet
Use promo code NEWBONUS

Claim £30 free bet & 20 Free Spins. Use the promo code NEWBONUS. New Hollywoodbets account holders. 18 years or older. United Kingdom residents only. T&Cs apply.

Bet at Hollywood bets
Under 178.5
O/U
@7/8 - 1 Unit
Bet £10 Get £30
with bonus code NEWBONUS

Available to new customers only. Make a qualifying deposit of £5 or more and claim the offer within 30 days of registering your account to qualify for 300% of that amount in Bet Credits, up to a maximum of £30 in Bet Credits. Once released, your Bet Credits will be held in your account balance and are non-withdrawable. Min deposit requirement. Free Bets are paid as Bet Credits and are available for use upon settlement of qualifying bets. Min odds, bet and payment method exclusions apply. Returns exclude Bet Credits stake. Registration required. Time limits and T&Cs apply. The bonus code NEWBONUS can be used during registration but does not change the offer amount in any way. #ad

Bet at bet365
Jack Martin
To Score 2+ goals
@13/10 - 1 Unit
Bet £20 Get £10
Use promo code NEWBONUS

18+ New customers only. Bet £20 (or more) EVS (2.0) or greater Get 2 x £5 Free Bets. 1 x £5 Free Bet paid automatically & following £5 Free Bet after 24hrs. Min Free Bet odds 4/1 (5.0) on accumulators Trebles & upwards. Expires after 24hrs. Full T&Cs apply. GambleAware.org

Bet at Star Sports

Top Betting Sites

special-offer-1Betting offers

Upcoming Events

09 May 2026

Geelong Cats v Collingwood Magpies

Hear more from Freetips.com