What England's Last 12 Years of Warm-Up Games Can Tell Us
England’s record in pre-tournament friendlies over the past decade shows that warm-up results have virtually no link to actual tournament performance. The key predictor of success is whether the manager uses these matches to solidify the starting XI and defense. Teams with settled lineups thrive, while those with rotation and experimentation struggle. England’s upcoming match against Costa Rica will be decisive; if Tuchel finalizes his core team, data predicts improved prospects. If he continues rotating players, history suggests England might underperform.
- Friendly results don’t predict England’s tournament success.
- Settling the starting XI & goalkeeper during warm-ups is crucial.
- Costa Rica friendly is the key test for lineup clarity before Texas.
England's pre-tournament friendly record is one of football's most misread datasets. The trope says warm-ups are meaningless.
The numbers say something more specific, and far more useful for anyone trying to read what Orlando will tell us about the Three Lions' chances in Texas a week later.
Across the last six major tournaments, England have played 13 warm-up friendlies under four different managers.
The pattern in those results predicts almost nothing about the tournament that followed. The pattern in the performances predicts almost everything.
Every England warm-up since 2014
| Tournament | Match | Result | Manager | Tournament Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2014 World Cup | England vs Peru | 3-0 W | Hodgson | Group-stage exit |
| 2014 World Cup | Ecuador vs England | 2-2 D | Hodgson | Group-stage exit |
| 2014 World Cup | England vs Honduras | 0-0 D | Hodgson | Group-stage exit |
| 2016 Euros | England vs Australia | 2-1 W | Hodgson | Round of 16 exit |
| 2018 World Cup | England vs Nigeria | 2-1 W | Southgate | Semi-final |
| 2018 World Cup | England vs Costa Rica | 2-0 W | Southgate | Semi-final |
| Euro 2020 | England vs Austria | 1-0 W | Southgate | Final |
| Euro 2020 | England vs Romania | 1-0 W | Southgate | Final |
| Euro 2024 | England vs Bosnia | 3-0 W | Southgate | Final |
| Euro 2024 | England vs Iceland | 0-1 L | Southgate | Final |
| 2026 World Cup | England vs New Zealand | W (1-0) | Tuchel | TBD |
*Note: The 2022 World Cup in Qatar had no traditional warm-up window because the tournament took place in November. England's preparation came through the September 2022 Nations League fixtures.
The headline finding
England have played 11 pre-tournament warm-ups across the last five summer tournaments. They have won seven, drawn two, lost one, and registered one to be decided.
The win rate of 64% sounds healthy. It is also almost completely uncorrelated with the tournament that followed.
The 2014 team won and drew their warm-ups. They were knocked out after two group games. The 2018 team won both warm-ups in a straightforward fashion.
They reached the semi-final. The 2024 team lost 1-0 at home to Iceland in the worst pre-tournament performance of the modern era. They reached the final.
The correlation between warm-up result and tournament outcome over the last 12 years sits close to zero.
What does correlate
Look beyond the scorelines and a different pattern emerges. The teams that prospered at tournaments had two things in common in their warm-ups, settled goalkeepers and a starting XI that played together.
The 2018 squad used the Nigeria and Costa Rica matches to lock in a back five and goalkeeper combination. Jordan Pickford started both. Kyle Walker, Harry Maguire, John Stones, Ashley Young and Kieran Trippier all featured.
The team that took the field against Tunisia in the opening group game contained six of the same players who started against Nigeria.
The 2024 squad did the same. Bosnia and Iceland produced a 1-0 loss in the headline result but settled a Pickford-led defence that conceded just three goals across seven Euros matches.
The teams that struggled did the opposite. The 2014 warm-ups featured rotating goalkeepers, an unclear midfield pairing and three different captains across three matches. Hodgson's side took an unsettled identity to Brazil and exited after two games.
The strongest predictor of tournament performance is not the warm-up result. It is the manager's clarity about his starting XI by the time the squad leaves the warm-up camp and file out at the World Cup.
Where Tuchel sits
The New Zealand friendly showed exactly the kind of mixed messaging the data warns against.
Tuchel described his own lineup as "mixed", with Jarell Quansah at right back, Jordan Henderson alongside Kobbie Mainoo in midfield, and a half-time reshuffle that put Bellingham in the captain's armband for the first time in the camp.
Tuchel's own words afterwards were instructive: "We have just four training sessions together and we mixed the team up completely so we never played before in these combinations." He has 14 or 15 players he is certain about.
England's friendly against Costa Rica is where the remaining three or four spots get decided.
That is the moment that matters more than the scoreline. England against a Costa Rica side that did not qualify for the tournament should produce a comfortable result. What it should also produce is the starting XI that takes the field in Dallas on 17 June.
The data point that should worry England fans
The 2014 warm-up matches and the 2026 warm-up so far share one specific feature. Both included extensive rotation, multiple goalkeepers across the matches, and a manager publicly experimenting with combinations a week before the opening group fixture.
The 2018, 2020 and 2024 sides went into their final warm-up knowing 10 of the 11 players who would start the tournament opener. The 2014 side did not. The 2026 side, as of Saturday, does not.
The Costa Rica match is the inflection point. If Tuchel uses Orlando to settle his team, the data says England's tournament prospects look comparable to 2018, 2020 and 2024. If he uses it to keep experimenting, the historical comparison gets uncomfortable.
What to look for on Wednesday
The single most important indicator is goalkeeping. Whichever of Jordan Pickford, Dean Henderson or Nick Pope starts against Costa Rica is England's tournament number one. That decision has settled every recent England side that prospered.
The second is the defensive shape. Six recent warm-up matches produced clean sheets. The defensive line in those matches was the same line that started the tournament opener. The link is causal, not coincidental.
The third is whether the starting XI looks like a starting XI. Tuchel has named players he is certain about. The Costa Rica friendly is the last chance to put them on the same pitch in the same positions before Croatia.
If 10 of the 11 players who start against Costa Rica are also the 10 who start against Croatia, the data says England are well placed. If only seven or eight of them are, the historical warning signs become harder to ignore.
Top Betting Sites
Betting offers
Upcoming Events
04 April 2026
23 May 2026
- LPL 2026 Split 2 Playoffs -
- Esports
- LCS 2026 Spring Playoffs -
- Esports
28 May 2026
- CDL 2026 Stage 4 Major Qualifiers -
- Esports
Load More
Today's Acca Tips
-
Soccer tips
-
Tennis tips
