• Home
  • Baseball

Tampa Bay Rays at Cleveland Guardians Betting Tips – Guardians To Regain Lead In MLB Playoffs Series

leigh-copson
Editor
Last updated: Sun 18 Oct 2026 12:48
The Cleveland Guardians are tipped to regain their series lead against the Tampa Bay Rays in their final ALCS home game. While Guardians' starter Parker Messick has yet to secure a win over Tampa this season, his playoff performances have been impressive and he has consistently contained the Rays’ offense. With the series tied at 2-2 and both teams displaying mixed forms, Cleveland’s chances hinge on stronger run support for Messick. The article’s main conclusion is that the Guardians can bounce back in Game 5 with improved batting.
Leigh Copson 2 hours ago
Share this article
Or copy link
  • Cleveland are 6-3 in last 9 home games
  • Parker Messick has limited Rays' offense this year, despite lacking wins against them
  • With stronger batting, Cleveland could regain the lead in Game 5
(Getty Images)
brand TB Rays @ CLE Guardians - Game 5 Live StreamWatch live online at bet365 > Baseball > MLB. T&Cs apply. Watch and bet Geo-restrictions apply. You must have a funded account or to have placed a bet in the last 24 hours. Over 18s only. T&Cs apply.

Cleveland are tipped to regain their series lead in their final home game in the ALCS.

Parker Messick's win/loss record against Tampa this season makes for ugly reading, but the All-Star left-hander has given up very little to the Rays in those losses and he has been outstanding in the playoffs so far.

If he gets more support from the bats, the Guardians can bounce back in Game 5.

Key Numbers – Can Guardians Make It 7 Wins In 10 Home Games?

  • Cleveland Guardians are 6-3 in their last 9 home games
  • The two starting pitchers have a combined ERA of 5.23
  • The Under has hit in all 3 of Parker Messicks starts against Tampa this season
  • The Under has cashedin 2 of Drew Rasmussen's starts against Cleveland in 2026

Guardians Lead All-Time Head-To-Head; Rays Won Last Meeting

  • Cleveland Guardians lead the all-time series 117-93
  • This MLB playoffs series is tied at 2-2
  • Tampa Bay Rays won 7-3 when the two teams last met on October 17

Tampa Bay Rays Form – Rays Down 2-1 In Series

Tampa Bay go into their final road game of this series having registered their fifth win in seven postseason games, levelling up this ALCS at 2-2.

DatePlayoff OppositionW/LScore
Oct-03 vs New York Yankees W 1-0
Oct-05 vs New York Yankees W 5-2
Oct-07 at New York Yankees W 4-3
Oct-12 vs Cleveland Guardians L 3-7
Oct-13 vs Cleveland Guardians W 3-1
Oct-15 at Cleveland Guardians L 2-3
Oct-17 at Cleveland Guardians W 7-3

Cleveland Guardians Form – Win Streak Ended In Game 2

Cleveland enter their last home game of this series on the back of their fourth defeat in nine playoff games, and locked at two wins apiece with the Rays.

DatePlayoff OppositionW/LScore
Oct-03 vs Chicago White Sox L 0-3
Oct-05 vs Chicago White Sox L 3-4
Oct-07 at Chicago White Sox W 9-3
Oct-08 at Chicago White Sox W 9-5
Oct-10 vs Chicago White Sox W 2-0
Oct-12 at Tampa Bay Rays W 7-3
Oct-13 at Tampa Bay Rays L 1-3
Oct-15 vs Tampa Bay Rays W 3-2
Oct-17 vs Tampa Bay Rays L 3-7

Starting Pitchers

PlayerTeamRecordERAStrikeoutsInnings
Drew Rasmussen Tampa Bay Rays 16-5 2.67 174 172.0
Parker Messick Cleveland Guardians 12-9 2.56 231 226.0

Verdict

Parker Messick is yet to beat Tampa as a starter this season, but that could change in Game 5.

Despite his ugly win/loss record, the Guardians starter has shut down the Rays' offense in 2026, so a little more support from his bats could see him finally break his duck as Cleveland take a 3-2 lead.

Best Bet1: Tampa Bay Win Moneyline @15/14 at bet365 - 3 Units
Best Bet2: Under 6.5 Total Runs @13/16 at dabble - 3 Units
Tampa Bay Win
Moneyline
@15/14 - 3 Units
Bet £10 Get £30
with bonus code NEWBONUS

Available to new customers only. Make a qualifying deposit of £5 or more and claim the offer within 30 days of registering your account to qualify for 300% of that amount in Bet Credits, up to a maximum of £30 in Bet Credits. Once released, your Bet Credits will be held in your account balance and are non-withdrawable. Min deposit requirement. Free Bets are paid as Bet Credits and are available for use upon settlement of qualifying bets. Min odds, bet and payment method exclusions apply. Returns exclude Bet Credits stake. Registration required. Time limits and T&Cs apply. The bonus code NEWBONUS can be used during registration but does not change the offer amount in any way. #ad

Bet at bet365
Under 6.5
Total Runs
@13/16 - 3 Units
Bet £10 Get £10
Promo Code: NEWBONUS

New customers only. Bet £10+ to receive £10 in Free Bets. 7-day free bet expiry. Stake not returned. Promotional Terms Apply. 18+. GambleAware.org

Bet at dabble
leigh-copson
Leigh Copson

Sports Editor • 25+ Years Experience, US & Combat Sports Specialist

US sports writer covering the NFL, NBA, NHL, boxing and MMA, with previews, predictions and betting tips across the major American leagues.

During his career at the Press Association and online sports sites including FreeTips and ExpertPicks.com, he has covered some of the biggest sporting events on the planet, including the Super Bowl, the Champions League Final and the World Cup Final.

He has also covered almost every major boxing match and UFC fight card during this time. His specialist sports are American Football, Basketball, Ice Hockey, Boxing, Mixed Martial Arts and Football.

Follow more of Leigh's work on Muckrack and connect with him on LinkedIn.

Read More

Top Betting Sites

special-offer-1Betting offers

Upcoming Events

18 Oct 2026

TB Rays @ CLE Guardians - Game 5

days

hours

min

Add to Calendar
Hear more from Freetips.com